Do We Really Need Another Transportation Tax?
Apr 06, 2017 12:00AM ● By By County Supervisor Sue Frost
Through the generosity of the Citrus Heights Messenger, this column serves to provide an update about matters affecting the community of Citrus Heights.
Soon after I got sworn into office, I issued a survey to our community to help me evaluate and improve our services based on what you want to see. The survey is now closed, and with over 2,500 total responses, conclusions based on the data can now be made.
To me, the most important question on the survey was the question relating to budget priorities. In every community within my district the number two priority is transportation/roads (with only public safety ranking higher). It’s clear that our entire community feels our roadways are in critical condition and that we can’t go much longer adding more to the deferred maintenance of the roads, which is currently at $450 million and counting.
This is a problem plaguing our entire state, with California’s deferred maintenance for transportation sitting at $57 billion. Unfortunately, many California legislators believe the best way to solve this problem is by raising taxes (again). There are two identical bills (AB 1 and SB 1) working their way through the legislative process that appear to be gaining steam and will hit taxpayers in three different ways. They would raise the gas tax by another 12 cents per gallon, they would hike the vehicle license fee by over 50%, and they would raise the cost of registering a vehicle by over 80%.
I urge our state legislators to reject these two proposals, and to find a solution without raising taxes and fees.
California has mismanaged its resources through waste, poured billions of dollars into an unnecessary high-speed rail system that does not even come close to addressing the state’s transportation problems, and devoted a greater and greater share of transportation funds to public transit (which accounts for only a small fraction of the total number of trips taken and has seen declining ridership). Bailing out such mismanagement with tax increases will only enable more of the same dysfunctional behavior. Until the state gets serious about putting its own house in order and making transportation a real priority, policymakers should put the brakes on any tax increases.
Further, lower-income taxpayers are disproportionately burdened by transportation taxes, since these households spend proportionally more of their income on things like gasoline and registration fees. For example, people making $24,000 a year spend more than twice as much of their income on gasoline as those earning five times as much. We should be doing what we can to assist families that are struggling, not further burden them.
Finally, I want to thank everyone who attended my Orangevale Community Cabinet meeting on April 7th - it was very helpful for me to discuss issues directly with the community. My next one will be on June 2nd at 7:30am at Annie’s Breakfast on Greenback and Beech. Thank you for reading - and as always, if you want to contact me, call me at 916-874-5491 or e-mail me at [email protected].
Sue Frost represents the 4th District, which includes all or part of the communities of Citrus Heights, Folsom, Orangevale, Antelope, Rio Linda, Elverta, Gold River, Rancho Murieta, North Highlands, Carmichael, Foothill Farms, and Fair Oaks.